The best silver vine toy depends on what you want it to do. A filled toy suits a cat that kicks and carries, a stick suits a cat that likes to chew, and powder suits topping up a scratcher or an old toy. If your cat ignores catnip, the part of the plant matters more than the shape of the toy.
In the main study, about 4 in 5 cats responded to silver vine, and almost 75% of the cats that ignored catnip responded to it too.
What kinds of silver vine toys are there?
There are four common types: chew sticks, powder, loose leafy blends and filled toys. They differ in how the cat meets the plant, how long the scent lasts and how much supervision they need.
| Type | How the cat uses it | Main trade-off |
|---|---|---|
| Chew sticks | Gnaws and rubs on it | Pieces can break off; strength varies |
| Powder | Sprinkled on a scratcher, bed or floor | Fades once exposed to air |
| Loose blend with catnip | Sprinkled or stuffed into a toy | Depends on what is in the mix |
| Filled toy | Kicks, bites, carries and rubs | A sealed toy cannot be topped up unless it is refillable |
PetMD, in an article written and reviewed by vets, lists the same forms: chew sticks, powder, a leafy mixture sold with catnip, and toys.
Which part of the plant should a toy contain?
Fruit galls are the part with the evidence. In Bol et al. (2017), the main trials used powder from dried fruit galls. In a follow-up with nine cats, the cats responded mainly to the galls, and only one responded to woodchips.
That is a small follow-up, so it does not prove that every stick is weak. It does mean a product that names only "silver vine" has not told you what you are buying. Look for the words fruit gall or matatabi fruit.
Are silver vine sticks safe to chew?
Sticks are safe for most cats when you watch the first sessions and take away a stick that starts to break. PetMD advises monitoring a cat very closely with any new chew or toy, because pieces that break off can cause choking or an intestinal obstruction.
It also says silver vine is not toxic, but a large amount can upset the stomach. Take the stick away when it splinters or wears down to a small piece. PetMD says chew sticks may also help remove plaque and tartar; ask a vet whether that applies to your cat.
Which silver vine toy suits which cat?
Match the toy to what your cat already does with toys.
| Cat | Try first | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Kicks and bites toys | Filled toy | The toy is built to be grabbed and kicked |
| Chews furniture and cardboard | Chew stick, supervised | It gives the chewing somewhere to go |
| Ignores catnip | Filled toy or powder made from fruit gall | About three in four catnip non-responders react to silver vine |
| Has a toy it already loves | Powder | Dusting an old toy costs very little |
| Kitten under 8 months | Wait, or expect little | PetMD says kittens this young will probably not react, or react less |
Should a silver vine toy also contain catnip?
A blend reaches more cats than either herb alone. About 2 in 3 cats respond to catnip and about 4 in 5 respond to silver vine, and a blend of the two reaches roughly 90% of cats. A silver vine toy with catnip is the safer buy if you do not know which herb your cat likes.
If you already know your cat ignores catnip, silver vine alone is fine. Catnip then adds nothing for that cat.
How long does a silver vine session last?
PetMD says the effect starts immediately and lasts up to 30 minutes. Keep the toy sealed between sessions so the scent lasts, and refresh a tired toy with fresh herb.
Where does Le Croissant fit?
Le Croissant is a filled toy, not a stick. It holds at least 30g of whole organic catnip buds and silver vine fruit galls inside reinforced OEKO-TEX cotton, hand-stitched in Toulouse. It suits cats that kick, bite and carry, and it reaches cats on either herb.
The trade-offs are plain. It costs more than most catnip toys, it is not refillable, and it gives a cat that only wants to chew wood nothing to gnaw. For that cat, a supervised stick is the better first buy.
Frequently asked questions
Do silver vine sticks work better than catnip?
Not necessarily. Silver vine reaches more cats than catnip, but the study that showed it used powder from fruit galls. A stick is mainly a chew toy, and in a small follow-up only one of nine cats responded to woodchips.
Can I give my cat silver vine every day?
The sources used here do not give a daily limit. PetMD says large amounts can upset the stomach, so offer short sessions and put the toy away between them.
Is silver vine the same as matatabi?
Yes. Matatabi is the Japanese name for the same plant, Actinidia polygama. Products sold under either name can be fruit gall, leaf or wood, so check which part is named.
Sources
- Bol S, Caspers J, Buckingham L, et al. (2017). Responsiveness of cats (Felidae) to silver vine (Actinidia polygama), Tatarian honeysuckle (Lonicera tatarica), valerian (Valeriana officinalis) and catnip (Nepeta cataria). BMC Veterinary Research 13:70.
- Madden A, DVM; reviewed by Morrison BJ, DVM. (2024). Silvervine Plant: An Alternative to Catnip. PetMD.