Dried catnip and catnip spray are not two versions of the same product. One is a filling and the other is a surface treatment. Mix them up and you end up with a dusty carpet, or a scratching post that smelled of something for an afternoon.
Nepetalactone, the oil that about two in three cats respond to, evaporates, and that is true in both formats. What differs is where the oil sits, how much you get and what you are actually trying to do.
Dried herb, when you want the cat to grab something
Dried leaf and flower is the right choice for anything the cat will hold, kick or eat a little of.
- Inside a toy. This is the only format that keeps working over months, and only if there is enough of it. Under 5g, padded with synthetic wadding, is the usual mass-market fill, and those toys go quiet within a fortnight. 30g or more, in a fabric that can hold oil, is a different thing.
- Loose, in tiny amounts. Some cats like to eat a pinch, which tends to make them sleepy rather than hyper. Stick to a pinch, because a bowl of it ends in vomit.
- Rubbed into cardboard. Corrugated scratchers hold dried particles in their ridges, whereas smooth wood and plastic do not.
Quality is easy to spot once you know what to look for. Good catnip is bright green with a sharp minty smell. Brown and hay-like is spent, and "catnip" with no mention of leaf or flower is often stem and dust.
Cotton takes up the oil and polyester does not, which is one reason a cheap plush mouse never smells of much, even when it is new.
Spray, when you do not want debris
Spray is distilled oil in water or alcohol. Use it on things you cannot open and do not want covered in leaf.
- Scratching posts. A light mist on the post, not the carpet around it, is the usual way to make a new post more interesting than the sofa.
- Carriers and beds. A little on a blanket, left to dry, can make a new object smell familiar. Do it well before you need the cat in the carrier, not as the taxi pulls up.
- Toys you cannot refill. Spray gives a closed toy a surface top-up, but it fades faster than a proper fill because it only sits on the outside.
Spray will not turn a 2g toy into a 30g toy. It puts a film of oil on the fabric, which is useful, but it is not the same as restocking the inside.
How to keep a stuffed toy alive
The oils leave when they meet air, heat and light. A toy on the living-room floor in summer is the worst case, and a toy in a jar in a cupboard is the best.
- Put it away after the session. Use an airtight glass jar or a heavy zip bag. Nothing else has as much effect on how long the smell lasts.
- Do not leave five herb toys out at once. The cat gets used to them, and the oils drift away into an empty room.
- Roll it before you offer it. Thirty seconds between your palms bruises the herb inside and brings fresh oil to the surface.
If a toy has gone quiet, smell it yourself. If it is sharp and minty, the cat is probably in a refractory period or bored of that particular toy. If it smells of hay or nothing, the oils are gone.
The jar method is the best way to revive a toy short of refilling it. Put the toy in a sealed jar with a tablespoon or two of good dried catnip for a few days. Cotton soaks the oil up well.
Washing
Hand wash in warm water with unscented soap, squeeze instead of wringing, press dry in a towel and air dry away from heat. Then re-scent the toy, because washing strips the surface oils. Use the jar method once it has dried, or a light spray once it is completely dry.
Skip the washing machine, the tumble dryer, fabric softener and bleach. The first two wreck the seams and the herb, and the last two leave a smell that covers whatever you put back.
How often to offer it
Two or three times a week is plenty. After a reaction the cat cannot respond again for 30 minutes to two hours, so a second session an hour later just wastes oil.
If your cat has never reacted to catnip, spraying more of it will not help. About one in three cats cannot respond to nepetalactone at all. Silver Vine reaches most of those cats, and a toy with both herbs avoids the question altogether.
That problem of quantity and blend is why we fill Le Croissant with 40g of organic catnip buds and Silver Vine fruit, in reinforced OEKO-TEX cotton that can be washed and put back in a jar. Spray is still the right tool for a scratching post, but it is a poor substitute for a toy that was under-filled to begin with.
If a toy that still smells of something is being ignored, the herb is not the problem.