There are three common reasons a cat ignores its toys, and buying another toy fixes none of them. Usually the toys have been out so long that the cat no longer notices them, or they do not move or feel like prey, or the herbs inside evaporated weeks ago.
Work through the list below in order. Most cats that "do not play" turn out to play perfectly well once one or two of these are fixed.
1. The toys have become part of the furniture
Cats get used to things fast. A stimulus that never changes stops carrying information, and a toy that has sat on the rug for three weeks has effectively become a small piece of decor.
That is why a basket of twenty toys produces less play than four toys on rotation. The cat is not spoiled for choice. It has stopped seeing any of them.
The fix takes five minutes. Put everything into a box, leave out three or four toys and swap them every few days. The same toys you were about to throw away will get attacked as if they were new, because as far as the cat is concerned, they are.
2. You are playing at the wrong time
Cats are crepuscular, so activity peaks around dawn and dusk and dips in the middle of the day. In many households that dip is exactly when someone has a free ten minutes to wave a wand toy around.
A cat that ignores a toy at 2pm may go after the same toy at 7pm without hesitation. Try early morning and early evening before you decide anything about the toy.
The other timing point is the order of events. Play first, then feed. The natural sequence is hunt, catch, eat, groom, sleep, and a session that ends with a meal makes sense to a cat in a way that one ending with you walking off does not.
3. The toy does not move like prey
This is the biggest problem with wand and string toys, and it comes down to technique.
Nothing a cat hunts ever moves towards it. A lure dragged at your cat's face looks like a threat, and the cat will back off or freeze. Move it away, along the floor, at an angle.
Then add the two things that really set off the chase:
- Concealment. Pull the toy behind a chair leg, under the edge of a rug or around a doorframe. Half-hidden prey is what makes a cat commit to stalking.
- Stopping. Real prey freezes, twitches, then bolts, and smooth continuous motion is the least interesting pattern there is. A toy that sits perfectly still and then jerks one inch can get a pounce from across the room.
And let the cat win. Ten minutes of chasing something it never catches leaves a cat frustrated, not satisfied, which is the main flaw in using a laser pointer on its own. If you use a laser, finish by landing the dot on a physical toy the cat can grab.
4. The herbs are dead
If the toy contains catnip or Silver Vine, this is the most likely explanation of all, and you cannot see it from the outside.
The compounds that make both herbs work are volatile oils, so they evaporate when they meet the air. A herb toy left out in a warm room loses noticeable strength within weeks. It looks identical, but the cat can tell the difference immediately.
There are two checks. Squeeze the toy hard and smell it, because fresh catnip is sharp and minty while spent catnip smells of dry hay or nothing at all. Then look at the colour of any visible herb. Bright green is good, and brown means the oils are gone.
Most cheap catnip toys also start out weak. Under 5g of herb, padded out with synthetic wadding, is common, which is why they feel dead within a fortnight of buying them.
5. Your cat physically cannot smell catnip
Roughly one cat in three has no response to catnip at all. Sensitivity to nepetalactone is inherited, so the cat either has the trait or it does not, and fresher or larger amounts will not change the outcome.
Owners of these cats often spend years assuming their cat is just serious. It is not. It is missing one receptor response, and there is a simple workaround.
Silver Vine works through different compounds, mainly nepetalactol and actinidine. A 2017 study found that around 75% of cats that ignore catnip do respond to Silver Vine. If catnip has never worked, this is the best thing to try.
This is why we fill Le Croissant with both herbs and do not pick just one. Organic catnip buds and Silver Vine fruit together cover both groups of cats, which takes the guesswork out, and 40g of it means the toy still has something to give in six months.
6. The toy is the wrong size
Small hard toys cannot be played with properly. A cat's most satisfying move is to grab with the front paws, pull the object into the belly and kick with the back legs. A plastic ball or a two-inch mouse cannot be held that way, so it gets batted once and abandoned.
The size that works is roughly the length of the cat's body from nose to shoulder, soft enough to bite into and heavy enough to feel like something. Cats that seem uninterested in all toys often turn out to be uninterested only in small toys.
7. The cat is watching you rather than the toy
Some cats will not commit while someone watches them closely, particularly nervous cats and particularly with a new object.
Put the toy down, walk away and do something else in the same room. A surprising number of cats that ignore a new toy in front of you will be carrying it around twenty minutes later.
The same goes for first introductions. Handing a toy straight to a cat rarely works, but leaving it somewhere the cat patrols usually does.
8. Something physical is in the way
If a cat that used to play has stopped, treat it as a symptom, not a preference.
Arthritis is the common cause, and it is often missed in cats, partly because they do not limp much and partly because owners put reduced jumping down to normal ageing. Dental pain stops cats biting toys, weight gain takes away the appetite for anything that needs a sprint, and poor vision changes what a cat can track.
A cat over about eight that has quietly given up on play deserves a vet check before you try anything else on this list.
Work through it in this order
- Put every toy away except three. Rotate every few days.
- Try again at dawn or dusk, not midday.
- Move the toy away from the cat, with pauses and hiding. Let them catch it.
- Squeeze and smell any herb toy. If it smells of hay, it is finished.
- If catnip has never worked, try Silver Vine.
- Try something bigger and softer that can be held and kicked.
- Leave the toy out and walk away.
- Book a vet check if a previously playful cat has stopped.
Almost every cat plays. The ones that seem not to are usually being offered the wrong object, at the wrong hour, moving the wrong way, or filled with herbs that stopped working a month ago.
Sources
- Bol S, Caspers J, Buckingham L, et al. (2017). Responsiveness of cats (Felidae) to silver vine (Actinidia polygama), Tatarian honeysuckle (Lonicera tatarica), valerian (Valeriana officinalis) and catnip (Nepeta cataria). BMC Veterinary Research 13:70.