Buy a friend's cat a gift that suits the kind of cat it is: a kitten needs something safe to chase, a bored indoor cat needs something new to do, and a cat that ignores toys needs a smell worth investigating. If you do not know the cat well, a toy filled with both catnip and silver vine is the safest guess, because it works on most cats.
This page is for choosing a present when the cat belongs to someone else. For general gifts for a cat you live with, see the main gift guide.
What should you ask your friend before buying?
Ask three things: how old the cat is, whether it lives indoors, and what it already plays with. The answers rule out most mistakes. A toy the cat already owns in five copies is a wasted gift, and a toy that is too small for a large cat is a swallowing risk.
If you cannot ask without spoiling the surprise, check the photos your friend has shared. A cat photographed beside a pile of toys has a different gift list from a cat asleep on a radiator.
What is the best gift for a kitten?
Choose a toy that is soft, light and too large to swallow, and that the kitten can attack without it falling apart. Kittens put everything in their mouths, so avoid anything with small glued-on parts, loose strings or bells.
A small plush toy that the kitten can carry works well, and a wand toy lets the owner play without using their hands as the target. Herbs are optional for the very young. Our guide to kitten toys explains what to look for.
What do you give a bored indoor cat?
Give it something that changes how it plays. An indoor cat that sleeps all day usually needs more variety, not more of the same toy. Three gifts that do that:
| Gift | Why it works |
|---|---|
| A wand or fishing-rod toy | The owner moves it like prey, so it works even for a cat that ignores toys left on the floor |
| A toy with catnip and silver vine | A new smell gives an old routine a reset, and a blend reaches roughly 90% of cats |
| A box or tunnel | Cheap and quick to set up, and many cats prefer it to the toy it came with |
Pair a toy with a window perch or a cardboard scratcher if you want the gift to feel bigger.
What if the cat ignores every toy?
Try scent before shape. About 2 in 3 cats respond to catnip, and about 4 in 5 respond to silver vine. Almost 75% of cats that ignore catnip react to silver vine, so a cat that has dismissed catnip toys may still respond to a silver vine one.
Check that the owner does not already know their cat is a non-responder to both. If they do, a wand toy or a food puzzle is the better present.
Which gifts are a bit different?
If you want the present to be remembered, pick something the owner would not buy for themselves:
- A refill or herb sampler. Whole catnip and silver vine, without a toy, so the owner can stuff or sprinkle their own.
- A handmade toy. Le Croissant is hand-stitched in Toulouse and holds both herbs in a shape cats grab and kick. It also looks good enough to leave on a shelf.
- A toy rotation box. Wrap four or five small toys together. The owner brings out one or two at a time, which keeps each toy interesting for longer.
- A personalised gift. A bandana or a name tag with the cat's name, if the owner already uses one.
Skip tinsel, ribbon and festive plastic toys. Cats swallow them, and the cat will not care about the theme.
Frequently asked questions
What is a good Christmas gift for someone else's cat?
A toy filled with catnip and silver vine is the safest choice when you do not know the cat, because the two herbs together reach roughly 90% of cats. If you know the cat well, match the gift to its age and habits.
What can I give a cat that ignores toys?
Try a different smell or a different way of playing. A silver vine toy suits many cats that ignore catnip, and a wand toy that the owner moves works for cats that never play alone.
Sources
- Bol S, Caspers J, Buckingham L, et al. (2017). Responsiveness of cats (Felidae) to silver vine (Actinidia polygama), Tatarian honeysuckle (Lonicera tatarica), valerian (Valeriana officinalis) and catnip (Nepeta cataria). BMC Veterinary Research 13:70.