Silver vine works on more cats than catnip. Roughly two in three cats respond to catnip, while silver vine reaches around 80% of cats, including about 75% of the ones that ignore catnip completely.
If your cat already loves catnip, either herb will do, so choose on price and quality. If your cat has never reacted to catnip, silver vine is what to try next, and the odds are good that it will work.
Silver vine vs catnip at a glance
| Feature | Catnip | Silver Vine |
|---|---|---|
| Plant | Nepeta cataria | Actinidia polygama |
| Also called | Catmint, catwort | Matatabi |
| Main active compound | Nepetalactone | Nepetalactol, plus actinidine and others |
| Cats that respond | Around 2 in 3 | Around 4 in 5 |
| Works on catnip non-responders | No | Yes, roughly 75% of them |
| Typical reaction length | 10 to 15 minutes | 10 to 15 minutes, often more chewing |
| Part used | Leaves and flowers | Dried fruit galls, or wood and bark |
| Shelf life in a toy | Months, fading steadily | Months, generally slower to fade |
| Availability | Everywhere | Less common outside specialist sellers |
The response rates, and where they come from
The number to remember for catnip is one in three, the share of cats that never respond. Sensitivity to nepetalactone is inherited, so a cat either has the trait or it does not. Age, breed, personality and fresher catnip will not turn a non-responder into a responder.
Silver vine's edge has been measured directly. In 2017 a study led by Sebastiaan Bol tested both plants on a large group of domestic cats. Of the cats that showed no response to catnip, about three quarters responded to silver vine, and overall it reached roughly 80% of the cats tested.
In practice, that means that if catnip has failed with your cat, you have probably been testing the wrong plant. Your cat is unlikely to be unusually serious.
Why silver vine reaches cats that catnip cannot
Catnip is chemically simple. It relies almost entirely on nepetalactone, so a cat that does not respond to that one compound has nothing else to react to.
Silver vine releases a mixture of compounds. Nepetalactol is the main one, alongside actinidine, iridomyrmecine and dihydroactinidiolide. Those compounds fit different olfactory receptors, so the mixture can activate a cat's reward pathway even when the nepetalactone route is closed.
Oddly, catnip contains far more of its attractant chemical, roughly forty times as much. It seems that variety in the chemistry matters more than quantity.
The two reactions look different
Both herbs set off the same broad sequence, but the emphasis differs enough that you will notice.
Catnip tends to produce the theatrical version, with cheek and chin rubbing against the source, rolling onto the back, vocalising and often a burst of sprinting. It looks like excitement, and it is the reaction most people picture.
Silver vine tends to bring more licking and chewing, longer face rubbing and rather more rolling. Cats often stay on the toy instead of running laps around the room, and owners often describe the reaction as more intense but less frantic.
Both wind down into a mellow, sleepy stretch. With catnip, eating a small amount skips the excited phase and goes more or less straight to the relaxed one.
The part of the plant matters more with silver vine
With catnip you want leaves and flowering tops, and you want them green, not brown. That part is simple.
Silver vine is sold in several forms, and they are not equivalent:
- Dried fruit galls, sold whole or ground into powder, are the most potent form. They are fruits deformed by a gall midge and carry the highest concentration of active compounds, so serious silver vine products use them.
- Wood and bark, usually sold as chew sticks. These are considerably weaker, although many cats enjoy gnawing them.
- Leaves are the least studied of the three. No published source we found ranks the parts of the plant by strength, so a product that names only "silver vine" has not told you what is inside.
If a product just says "silver vine" without naming the part, assume it is not the fruit gall. The good stuff costs enough that sellers say so.
How long each one lasts
The active compounds in both plants are volatile oils, so they evaporate, and that is why toys fade.
In practice, silver vine holds up somewhat better over the months, and powdered fruit gall copes better with being left out in the open. Catnip fades faster and you can see it happen, as bright green leaf with a sharp smell turns brown and hay-like.
Storage matters more than the choice of herb. A toy kept in a sealed jar between sessions stays strong for months. The same toy left on the living room floor is noticeably weaker within weeks, and the cat will have stopped noticing it long before the herbs are really spent.
Safety, and the refractory period
Neither plant is addictive or toxic, and cats tend to regulate themselves well. A small amount of either is fine to eat. A cat that eats a large quantity may vomit or have loose stools, which clears up on its own.
Both herbs share a refractory period. After a reaction, the olfactory receptors stop responding for roughly 30 minutes to two hours, and no amount of fresh herb will start a second round. That is normal, and it is why toys are better put away between sessions than left out.
Kittens are a special case. Sensitivity to either plant usually does not appear until a kitten is three to six months old, so a kitten that ignores both tells you nothing yet.
So which should you buy?
If your cat responds to catnip. Either works. Choose on the quality of the toy and the amount of herb inside, not on which plant it is.
If your cat ignores catnip. Try silver vine, preferably the fruit gall form. Three in four catnip non-responders react to it.
If you are buying a gift and cannot test first. Choose a toy with both herbs. You cannot know which side of the genetic divide the cat is on, and a single-herb toy is a coin toss you can avoid.
If your cat is elderly or unwell. Silver vine is often the better bet, since the response to catnip can weaken with age while the response to silver vine tends to hold up.
Why we stopped choosing
We make Le Croissant with both herbs for the reason above. The two work through separate chemical routes, so a blend reaches cats that either herb alone would miss. It holds 40g of organic catnip buds and silver vine fruit inside reinforced OEKO-TEX cotton, hand-stitched in the South of France.
The quantity is deliberate. Most mass-produced catnip toys contain under 5g and pad the rest with synthetic filler, which is the real reason they feel dead after a week. You can read more about the chemistry behind the blend on our science page.
How to test your own cat properly
If you want a clear answer instead of a guess, test it properly.
- Test one herb at a time, at least two hours apart, so the refractory period does not mask the second result.
- Use fresh material. That means bright green catnip or silver vine fruit gall powder. Stale herb gives a false negative.
- Bruise it first. Crush the herb between your fingers to release the oils.
- Give the cat space. Cats are much less likely to engage while you watch closely, so put the herb down and step back.
- Wait a couple of minutes. Some cats sniff, walk off and come back.
A cat that ignores both herbs, more than once, on fresh material, really is a non-responder to both. It happens, and herbs will not fix it. In that case, focus on texture, shape and movement instead.
Sources
- Bol S, Caspers J, Buckingham L, et al. (2017). Responsiveness of cats (Felidae) to silver vine (Actinidia polygama), Tatarian honeysuckle (Lonicera tatarica), valerian (Valeriana officinalis) and catnip (Nepeta cataria). BMC Veterinary Research 13:70.
- Uenoyama R, Miyazaki T, Hurst JL, et al. (2021). The characteristic response of domestic cats to plant iridoids allows them to gain chemical defense against mosquitoes. Science Advances 7(4): eabd9135.
- Todd NB. (1962). Inheritance of the catnip response in domestic cats. Journal of Heredity 53(2): 54-56.