Most Christmas gifts for cat owners fail for the same reason, which is that they are novelty items. Think of a mug with ears, a doormat with a pun or a moulded plastic toy in neon colours. The gifts that last past January have one thing in common: they work for the person's home as well as for their cat.
So the question to ask is not "what do cat people like?" but "what will still be on the shelf in March?". Here is what to buy, grouped by who you are really buying for.
Are you buying for the person or the cat?
It sounds obvious, but this is what people get wrong most often. A gift for the cat is judged by the cat, and cats are harsh critics. A gift for the owner is judged on whether they would have picked it themselves.
If you know the person well, buy for the cat. Owners enjoy watching a new toy get demolished, and it takes the guesswork out of size and taste. If you only know them a little, buy for the person and choose something that is cat-shaped but not cat-themed.
This page is about gifts for the person. Gifts for the cat itself are in the guide below, and a separate guide covers gifts for a friend's cat when you do not know it well.
Gifts that don't look like pet products
Nobody warns you before you get a cat that your living room will slowly fill with objects the colour of children's playground equipment. There are scratching posts covered in carpet offcuts, bright plastic balls with bells inside and a tunnel in three clashing patterns.
That is why a good-looking cat product makes such a welcome gift. You are not only giving a toy, you are giving someone one less eyesore.
Things worth looking for:
- Toys made from natural fabric, not moulded plastic. Cotton, wool felt and undyed canvas all sit quietly in a room. They also feel better under a cat's paws and teeth, which matters more than you might think.
- Undyed sisal or wood scratching posts. Sisal lasts far longer than carpet and does not shed fibres into the rug.
- A ceramic or stainless steel water bowl, wide and shallow. Cats dislike pressing their whiskers against the sides of a deep bowl, and ceramic does not hold the smell of old water the way plastic does.
- Wall-mounted wooden shelves. In a small flat, vertical space is the best upgrade you can give an indoor cat.
Our own Le Croissant began with exactly this frustration. It is hand-stitched in the South of France from OEKO-TEX certified cotton and filled with a blend of organic catnip buds and Silver Vine fruit, so it holds a cat's attention without looking as if it came out of a toy box. People leave it on the coffee table, which is not something anyone says about a plastic mouse.
For the person who already has everything
Three approaches work reliably here.
Make it specific to their cat. Anything with the cat's name on it moves a gift from "nice thing" to "kept forever". Embroidery, a collar tag and a small commissioned drawing all work. Le Croissant can be embroidered with a cat's name for this reason, and it is the option people choose most often in December.
Give something that gets used up. Consumables avoid the problem of owning everything already. A pot of growing catnip is a good example, since it is a plant for the windowsill and a supply for refilling toys later.
Give something they would not buy for themselves. Most owners economise on their cat's toys because toys get destroyed. A single well-made one, bought by someone else, is a small luxury they would have talked themselves out of.
Small gifts, Secret Santa and stocking fillers
Budget gifts are where plastic tat does the most damage, because a low price is used as an excuse for low quality. You do not have to accept that.
At the cheapest end, a bag of good loose dried catnip or a small pot of Silver Vine powder costs very little and is really useful. Owners use it to refill toys and refresh scratching posts. Look for a strong green colour and a sharp smell, because brown, hay-scented catnip has already lost most of its oils.
One step up, a single well-made toy is the classic Secret Santa answer for anyone with a cat. It is easy to wrap, needs no size guessing and cannot clash with anyone's decor if you pick natural materials.
At the top of a small budget, look for something personalised. Adding a cat's name raises the perceived value far more than it adds to the cost.
What to skip
- Anything with glued-on feathers, bells or googly eyes. These come off in the first serious play session and end up on the floor next to a cat that puts things in its mouth.
- Cat clothing. A tiny handful of cats put up with it. The rest will make their feelings known, and the owner has to take it off.
- Large cat trees, unless you have been asked. The owner has measured their space and thought about sight lines, and you have not.
- Laser pointers on their own. They are fine as part of a play routine, but a chase with nothing to catch at the end leaves some cats wound up and not satisfied. Pair one with a toy the cat can really grab.
- Scented candles and diffusers marketed at pet homes. Several essential oils are not safe around cats, and a gift that has to be researched before it can be used is not much of a gift.
A short checklist before you buy
Ask these four questions before you buy:
- Would it still look fine left out on the floor? If not, it will be put away, and a toy that gets put away gets forgotten.
- Can any part of it come off in a cat's mouth? Small parts, glued trim and thin elastic are all reasons to put it back.
- Is it made of something that survives claws? Reinforced cotton and sisal hold up, while thin polyester splits along the seam.
- Does it need the owner to do anything? Assembly, batteries and research all lower the odds of it being used.
Almost everything that passes all four is natural, simple and made a bit better than it needed to be. That is a narrower choice than the pet aisle suggests, which is good news in December because you can stop scrolling much sooner.
If you are filling a stocking for the cat instead of buying for the owner, the picks are a little different.