Most catnip toys hold under 5 grams of herb, and a fair share of that is already spent by the time you buy it. That is the biggest reason toys "stop working" after a week or two: there was never much in there to begin with.
There is no official minimum, but in practice you want enough that the toy has real weight and still has oil to give months later. That means far more than a pinch.
Why under 5g fades so fast
A few grams of catnip, especially crushed leaf padded out with synthetic wadding, holds only a small reserve of a volatile oil. Volatile means it evaporates when it meets the air, and a small reserve runs out quickly.
So the toy smells convincing in the packet, gets a good first session and then goes quiet. The cat has not used up the herb so much as the room has.
Why quantity changes the behaviour
A toy holding 30g or more is a different object altogether. There is enough herb that everyday evaporation does not empty it, and enough that a cat opening a few glands per session still leaves plenty for next week.
A bigger fill also gives the toy weight, which matters for how cats really play. A cat grabs a toy with its front paws, pulls it into its belly and kicks with its back legs, and that needs something to push against. A thin shell with a handful of wadding collapses and stops being interesting. A densely filled toy pushes back.
Quantity is not the only lever
More herb helps, but the form and the part of the plant matter just as much.
- Whole buds stay sealed until the cat bites, so they keep their oil far longer than the same weight of powder.
- The right part of the plant counts, since buds and flowering tops carry the oil and stems barely any.
- A second herb covers the cats that catnip cannot reach. Around one in three do not respond to catnip at all.
30g of ground, stem-heavy, half-spent leaf would still disappoint, whereas 30g of whole buds delivers.
How to judge fill before buying
You cannot weigh a toy through a screen, so look for clues.
- Does the listing state a weight? A brand that fills generously usually says so, and silence usually means a pinch.
- Does it feel dense in the hand, if you can try it in a shop? Squeeze it. A good kicker toy feels as if it contains something, and an airy one does not.
- Is the herb whole or dust? Visible whole buds last longer than fine powder.
- Is it padded with synthetic wadding? Wadding plus a token pinch is the cheap formula, a toy with the shape but not the substance.
What we fill, and why that number
We put 40g of organic catnip buds and Silver Vine fruit into Le Croissant, kept whole, inside reinforced OEKO-TEX cotton. The figure is deliberate. It is roughly eight times the fill of a typical mass-market toy, and that is the difference between a toy that fades in a fortnight and one that still works after six months.
The Silver Vine is there for a different reason. It reaches the cats that do not respond to catnip, so the fill is not only large but also works for more cats.