Not every part of the catnip plant is equally strong. The buds and flowering tops hold the most oil, the leaves hold a fair amount, and the stems hold almost none. When a product just says "catnip", you should ask which of those three parts you are paying for.
It matters because cheap catnip is often mostly stem and coarse leaf, ground up so you cannot tell. The bag looks full, but it behaves like a weak one.
Why the parts differ
Nepetalactone, the compound cats respond to, is stored in glands on the surface of the leaves and in higher concentration on the flowering tops and the buds around them. The stem is there for structure. It carries water, holds the plant up and contains very little oil.
So the ranking is not marketing spin. It simply reflects where the plant keeps its chemistry.
Buds and flowering tops
This is the potent part. As catnip comes into bloom, the oil peaks in and around the flowers, which is why growers harvest at first bloom and do not wait.
Buds also hold up best over time, especially if they are kept whole instead of crushed, because more of the oil stays sealed inside intact glands.
If a product names buds or flowering tops, that is a good sign. They are the most expensive part to supply, so sellers mention them when they are there.
Leaves
Leaves carry a decent amount of oil and make up most dried catnip. Good-quality leaf, dried in the dark and kept sealed, works perfectly well.
The catch is that leaf degrades easily. If it is dried in sunlight, stored somewhere warm or crushed to powder, it loses its oil quickly. "Leaf" can therefore mean a strong herb or a tired one, depending entirely on how it was handled.
Stems
Stems are filler. They add weight and volume but not much scent, so a bag full of chopped stem looks generous and does very little for the cat.
Low-end catnip uses stems to pad out the weight. Grinding the whole plant, stems included, makes a cheaper product that shows the same weight on the label but underperforms inside the toy.
How to read a bag or a toy
- A named part beats no name. "Buds", "flowering tops" or "leaf" tells you something, while "catnip" alone does not.
- Look at the mix. Visible woody bits and long fibrous pieces mean stem. Fine green material with flower clusters is a better sign.
- Colour and smell still decide it. Bright green and sharp means potent, and brown and hay-like means spent, whichever part it started as.
- Powder hides everything. Once the plant is ground to dust you cannot see what is in it, and dust fades fastest anyway.
Why this decides how a toy performs
Two toys can both say "filled with catnip" and behave completely differently. One holds 30g of whole buds, and the other a few grams of ground whole plant, stems and all. The label does not tell them apart, but the cat does, straight away.
That is why we are so specific about it. Le Croissant is filled with organic catnip buds and Silver Vine fruit, kept whole and packed at 40g inside reinforced OEKO-TEX cotton. We use buds because that is where the oil is, we keep them whole so the oil stays put, and we use enough that the toy still has something to give in six months.